Boy I'm glad someone is putting out dance music of this quality out these days of commercialism. I only became aware of the The Soft Pink Truth about 3 years ago even though Drew Daniel has been producing music under this moniker for over 20 years. It continues, fresh as ever.
From Pitchfork:
Was It Ever Real? gives the impression of a brawny, fulfilling eroticism. The title alone of “Is It Going to Get Any Deeper Than This?,” not to mention the seductive moans and sighs that flutter throughout the mix like plumes of smoke, make the record’s preoccupations clear from its opening moments. Coil’s original 1986 “Anal Staircase” is a Stravinsky-sampling bruiser that seems to invite the listener to hitherto unknown pleasures, but Daniel replaces the unsettling laughter on the original with a smattering of lounge ambiance, and Balance’s screams simmer down to a close-mic’d whisper. This is a vision of sex not as something forbidding or forbidden but a healthy component of a comfortable life. The anal staircase is carpeted in velvet.
Daniel commits to a luxe version of deep house on these four tracks, ripe with vestiges of disco. The bass is big and plummy, and electric pianos mumble and splutter. The title track exists to flex this style. Acetone’s Mark Lightcap soars with a guitar lead that brings to mind the ‘70s-sleaze Shaft school of seduction, while a harpsichord performance from Tom Boram elevates the whole thing into the kind of orgiastic paradise-garden fantasy Prince conjured on the late-‘80s deep cut “Adonis & Bathsheba.” The pitch-shifted hi-hats, which seem to squelch through mud, impart a whiff of the peaty fertility of early-2000s albums by Matthew Herbert (whose challenge to Daniel to make house music led to the start of the Soft Pink Truth).
Much of the Soft Pink Truth’s catalog is devoted to provocative electronic tributes to genres like hardcore, black metal, and crust punk. This is his first project-length pastiche that isn’t a complete subversion, and it continues the turn away from “angry-white-guy music” that Daniel commenced on 2020’s beatific Shall We Go On Sinning So That Grace May Increase? Like that record, Was It Ever Real? is a luxe, collab-heavy work that’s easier on the ears than most of his music. Unlike Sinning, this is a straight-faced genre experiment, leaning into club music’s carnal qualities without exaggerating them or sending them up, tunneling toward the center of classic deep house rather than scratching at its margins as Daniel did on his 2003 debut Do You Party?
From Resident Advisor:
Depth in this situation doesn't mean the ideological, intellectual or thematic kind, but instead a type of immersion—the feeling of being transported into another world. Deep house retains the dynamic range of disco, where pianos and horns glimmer out of the mix as strings and synths simmer far away. Daniel employs a massive cast of collaborators in order to foster that three-dimensional feeling, from regulars like saxophonist Andrew Bernstein and his house-diva-of-choice Jenn Wasner to new faces like string arranger Uras Kurugullu and all manner of horn players, harpists, flautists and percussionists. The four-on-the-floor kick drum keeps the listener on a one-way track into the bowels of the 70-minute LP. Daniel does this by masterfully manipulating the mood of the album so that it's one thing and then another thing. without the listener ever really noticing the change. "Deeper" opens with 11 minutes of deluxe instrumental disco inflected with Latin percussion and loping rhythm guitars. Daniel keeps the groove going just long enough that we forget what we're listening to. Once we've started to settle in, here comes Xiu Xiu singer Jamie Stewart hamming it up on the Georges Bataille-referencing "La Joie Devant La Mort," taking exquisite queer melancholia to the edge of self-parody in that highwire way only Stewart can. Now that we know Daniel's going to use vocals, it's time to hear him do something beautiful with them: "Wanna Know" is a full-on pop song, with Wasner contributing saccharine Bee Gees harmonies. "Wanna Know" is probably going to be the all-time Soft Pink Truth banger, the one that ends up in playlists and party scenes in indie movies. Yet it does a great job of deepening the album—it's this record's "Tessio." Then it disappears back into the fog and smoke, and after a few minutes of "Trocadero" we realize, with a start, that there haven't been vocals for a while. Is It Going To Get Any Deeper Than This? proceeds like that for 70 minutes. It's deep, then it's funny, then it's pretty, then it's deep again, then it's funny again, then it's deep again. Actually, it's often at least two of these things at the same time. If the LP doesn't succeed at being the deepest album of all time, it's because of "Sunwash," a 13-minute Tangerine Dream-style sequencer fantasia that builds endless anticipation at the moment the album should be at its spookiest and most plangent. But it's hilarious when "Deeper Than This?" interrupts with close-mic'd, cartoonishly seductive French dialogue.

From Anthony D'Amico:
The album kicks off in style with its first certified banger, "Deeper," which deceptively fades in with bleary drones before launching into a straight up classic disco groove with all the requisite hand claps and funky guitars. There is enough subtle dissonance to give it a somewhat delirious and unreal feeling right from the jump, but things do not get truly art-damaged until an unexpected church bell passage subsides. While the groove remains unswervingly propulsive for a bit longer, the insistent sexy thump is increasingly mingled with generous helpings of kitschy string stabs, tropical-sounding guitars, hazy flutes, and a host of other inspired psych touches before it all dissolves into smeary abstraction. I suppose the extended running time and ambient comedown preclude "Deeper" from being a hot single, but several of the pieces that immediately follow gamely rekindle the dancefloor fire. "La Joie Devant La Mort" is one of the album's more "perverse pop moments," as Jaime Stewart sings a George Bataille line about being in search of joy before death over an endearingly weird groove that calls to mind Coil's Love's Secret Domain album colliding with "A Fifth of Beethoven" and a chorus of tiny frogs. Wasner then takes the mic for the breezily sensuous "Wanna Know," which milks the album title's question for all its worth over a groove that could have been plucked from a Love Unlimited Orchestra album. The following "Trocadero" then pays homage to the "sleaze" disco subgenre synonymous with the titular SF club before "Mood Swing" ends the first half with a killer slow-building disco fusion of spiritual jazz, gurgling psychedelia, and Reich-ian piano patterns.
The second half is a bit more abstract and eclectic, as the 13-minute "Sunwash" is a chilled out bit of synthy Tangerine Dream-inspired spaciness. To some degree, It feels like it belongs on a completely different album than everything that came before it, but it makes a fine palate cleanser and it technically is on a different album vinyl-wise (Deeper is a double LP). The languorously dub-inflected "Joybreath" extends that post-club "morning after" vibe further, as Rose E Kross whispers and murmurs Bataille lines in French as twinkling piano and bleary sax and vibraphone melodies lazily wander through a fuzzy dreamscape. I imagine it evokes the feeling of waking up on a beach at sunrise after a hedonistic night of dancing and substance abuse, but my life is far too boring for me to be entirely certain of that. A couple of curious detours then follow, but the album ends on an incredibly strong note with a swooning cover of Willie Hutch's "Now That It's All Over" that feels half "psychotropic exotica bliss" and half "Love Boat" theme. It's a fittingly beautiful and poignant end to the album, as Daniel arguably sheds all of his ironic, sophisticated, and avant-garde tendencies for six minutes of pure naked joy (albeit pure naked joy repurposed from a blaxploitation classic). In any case, it is one hell of a cover as well as the perfect end to a thoroughly enjoyable album. And, of course, both Deeper and Was It Ever Real? have earned a permanent place in my heart for being primarily inspired by an anonymous woman's decades-old grievance with a club DJ.
