From PopMatters:
You can’t be accused of harassing only the Latinos in the mall,
you’d be harassing everyone – it just so happens that everyone’s
Latino. And even better: if you do it during business hours, you can be
pretty sure that almost no one you harass will be some easily-ruffled
art patron, paralegal, or clerk of the Cook County Recorder of Deeds.
No, almost everyone is low-income, and unconnected with anyone more
powerful than the manager of a grocery store. All right, if you’re
really unlucky you might harass the relative of an alderman. But the
alderman of Little Village is going to be Latino, too.
See, all you really want to do is make sure anyone who’s going to
complain is Latino. That way, anyone from the rest of the population
watching TV who sees people complaining about Gestapo tactics will see
only people who look like brown immigrants. And they’ll say to
themselves, “There go all those brown immigrants who come to take our
jobs, complaining about America again. If they don’t like it, why don’t
they go back where they came from? You know, to that other, not as good
America.”
The Nazis tried to avoid dramatic scenes where regular Germans could
see them harassing Jews right in their midst, at least early on – they
didn’t throw cordons around high-society balls just because a couple of
Jews were attending. It always worked out better for the Nazis when
they harassed Jews in the Jewish neighborhoods. That’s why they put
them in ghettos, silly! Even European anti-Semites could be annoyed by
being cordoned off in a block of cafes at tea time, even if it was in
the name of ferreting out the dirty Jew, and don’t get me started with
your dozen or so less-than-rabidly-anti-Semitic Germans – they had no
stomach for that stuff whatsoever.
On the other hand, it is nice to know that the quaint custom of
treating immigrant populations as animals to be corralled hasn’t
completely died out in the West. You think Sarkozy’s doing so well in
France because voters think he’s going to shorten the work week? Let
alone make everyone equal under French law? Egalite? I don’t think so.
Maybe Fraternite, as long as mon frere is a frere by blood. Liberte?
Well, the West always has that. It’s the West! The West invented la
Liberte.
Anti-immigrant Nationalism has never really gone out of style in the
West – or anywhere. It’s just that with the leader of the Free World
pushing discourse so far to the right – if you can call monarchy
“right” – all right, pushing discourse so many centuries back into the
pre-republic past, back to the days before Italian Humanism, back
before Machiavelli saw a market for his ideas – it’s made scared, angry
majorities nostalgic for the days when you could just round up the
troublemaking outsiders and massacre them. It’s like when white people
in the USA start singing songs about watching the darkies picking
cotton, or when a group of Germans start singing “Deutschland Uber
Alles” or the “Horst Wessel” song, they get all misty-eyed and long for
the good old days.
More