From Aram Sanreich's "Mashed Up" at truthdig:
The line separating artists from their
audience has always been a bit blurry. From that moment during the
Renaissance when someone first decided that a painter was more than just
a craftsman with an easel, the whole idea of the
Artist-with-a-capital-A has required an entire mythology just to make it
seem plausible.
The biggest myth of all is the Romantic
notion that artists somehow create their work uniquely and from scratch,
that paintings and sculptures and songs emerge fully-formed from their
fertile minds like Athena sprang from Zeus. Running a close second is
the myth that only a handful of us possess the raw talent – or the
genius – to be an artist. According to this myth, the vast majority of
us may be able to appreciate art to some degree, but we will never have
what it takes to make it. The third myth is that an artist’s success
(posthumous though it may be) is proof positive of his worthiness, that
the marketplace for art and music functions as some kind of aesthetic
meritocracy.
Of course, these myths fly in the face of
our everyday experience. We know rationally that Picasso’s cubism looks a
lot like Braque’s, and that Michael Jackson sounds a lot like James
Brown at 45 RPM. We doodle and sing and dance our way through our days,
improvising and embellishing the mundane aspects of our existence with
countless unheralded acts of creativity. And we all know that American Idol
and its ilk are total B.S. (very entertaining B.S., of course!). Each
of us can number among our acquaintance wonderful singers, dancers,
painters or writers whose creations rival or outstrip those of their
famous counterparts, just as each of us knows at least one beauty who
puts the faces on the covers of glossy magazines to shame.
And yet, we believe the myths. How could we
not? Who among us has the time, the energy, or even the motivation to
buck the overwhelming support the myth of the Artist receives from the
institutions that govern our society – to dispute our schools, our
churches, even our laws? What is copyright, after all, but the legal
assertion of an individual’s sole ownership over a unique artifact of
creative expression? These laws, sometimes enforced at gunpoint, require
us to believe the myths, or face the consequences.
More